Sunday, 31 December 2006
I Watched With Teeth In My Sockets
Under Freudian standard, everyone is fucked in the head one way or another.
The difference is how fucked are you inside?
I'm guilty of a conscious mixed of voyeur and sadism.
Does that meant that I enjoyed watching people changing clothes, or that I grabbed every opportunity to sneak a peek at people's panties or beat up my girlfriend for sexual pleasure?
No.
That I would have to disagree with Freud that every emotion deviates and character breakdown have to be sexual fueled.
My conscious mixed of voyeur and sadism have to do with the everyday observation of the common people around me.
Everyone observe people too. Yeah, that's correct.
But I feel the wrong emotions at the wrong circumstances. That's where I'm guilty.
Working in hospital, there are lots of chances to see tired family members crying along the corridors.
Every time when I see them, I feel something else inside. My inside didn't soften, instead it is something curiously intense. It'll make me grateful and guilty at the same time.
It is wrong and I can't help it.
We went drinking on friday night, at this uncle uncle pub at Tanjong Pagar. It was the Chinese pub setting; with crowding round tables, cards playing, several hanging televisions for karaoke, a large pool table in the background and busy hostesses around to serve the customers. The crowd was made up of men in their forties and late thirties, which made us felt like sixteen year olds.
The young hostesses' job scope was to engage the customers, playing cards with them or chatting with them at expense of an order of a drink. The customers were allowed to interact with them in intimate distance, and occasionally touch them with a hug or their hands by the ladies' hip/shoulder. It was all sensual, nothing sexual.
Watching them hop around tables to interact closely with the middle aged uncles, Marx raised, 'How do they do that?'
Me: 'It's a job. It's all for the money. That's how you straighten your thoughts. It's a job that requires you to have fun with dirty old men. That's that.'
We looked at each other and emptied our drinks in silence.
I have a weak bladder and that condition will always remind me whenever I'm having fun. I got to the toilet and it was locked. While waiting outside, an hostess hurried over to the sink outside the toilet. She was plump and unpleasantly looking. She looked at herself in the mirror and tried to wipe the tears along her mascara. She was crying by the dirty sink by the red piece of cracked wall, the dark hued lightscape and her mascara smearing.
She tried to calm herself down but uncontrollably she broke into more tears. Her tired shoulder shrugged as she couldn't stop bawling in desperate silent. She noticed that I was looking at her. She whispered a sorry, she tried to collect herself together but the tears just couldn't stop brimming out from her reddish face.
To avoid further embarrassment, she walked off.
That night, I couldn't stop thinking of the image of the hostess weeping by the sink in the red background of dim lightscape and smeared mascara.
That imagery was so soulfully beautiful and curiously captivating.
I'm such a jerk.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Ur friend's called Marx? haha Marxism..u know according to Marxist theory, operas, classical music and Shakespeare works fall under the heading of high culture. Low culture will then refer to the wide variety of culture for and by the masses..so maybe for this incident, she was crying because she didnt think highly of herself? But .. IMO, not that low class yet..hope not.. so poor thing
ReplyDeleteInterestingly, in the history of Chinese culture - artist, poets and actors are of the lowest denominations, lower than prostitutes, ranked by "contributions to the nation". Thanks to the patriachal archetypes as well as capitalistic idealism (China being one of the most advanced civilisation before Zhu Di brought China down financially)... Unlike western culture where art was for the bourgeois in the past and hardly secular... art was much secularly propelled in the Chinese history.
ReplyDeleteSorry Raknax, I digressed. The thought of the lady crying spun thoughts and I was thinking that, ironically to us Chinese, everything in life is an art. And for the lady, it's an art to socialise with customers. I do not intend to second guess her reasons, I am not empowered to. Just the thought of practicing such art in a social culture can be quite stressful (being quite a closet anti-socialist myself)... so, much was felt and I could almost picture the scenario like a WKW's film. LOL... life's tough eh?
princess:
ReplyDeletefriend's name Marcus, but i often refer him as Marx in my site.
Marxism sia... According to that vision, such uncle uncle pub will never exist and hostesses weeping by a corner? Impossible! For Karl was for anti-exploitation and he was a feminist too.
I think that hostess was crying because a customer bullied her?
Have you watched Confession Of Pain? It might explain a lot.
slepwlker:
ReplyDeleteWong Kar Wei? Yes, maybe so. But WKW's characters are often too pridefully numb and over self-indulged (Chungqing Express and 2046 are very good examples) to cry in front of other people.
and everything is art? Yeah,and because I feel that too, I feel like a jerk too. Where's the humanity? Why did I choose to watch her cry instead of offering some help? A girl crying and I was just standing there... In a bigger picture, it is indeed helplessly romantic, but on personal level wise,I should be a gentleman (which if Jane Austen was alive, she probably would stick an umbrella up my ass), maybe ask her how is she?
I can't help myself.
Not offering help and not asking why might be a kind of respect to her, I am just wondering, do you feel sympathy?
ReplyDeletesympathy? sympathy is easy to feel, but i don't quite think that i have the right to sympathize her.
ReplyDeleteno, i don't.
i felt responsible that we were there in that short corner by chance and i choose to be pedestrian.
perhaps women's tears have this paramount effect upon me. It stops time and breaks a heart into shattering pieces.
Sometimes being a gentleman is not doing anything at that moment bcoz it will just embarass her more. She might want to be by her self and let it out... But we wouldn't know wat's the real situation's like so all that I said will be just stipulations... :)
ReplyDeleteSometimes self-indulgence is put up... and I see Wong Kah Wai scenario in you... she probably is not the main character... do you get the picture now, hmmm? (hehe) Anyway, I do see a lot of crying in the film "in the mood for love"... they are just not externalized. The alienation of "being" and "non-being" makes WKW's film very existential? I don't know... but it makes you feel more because of the romanticism in absurdm...
Anyway Raknax, I am doing a show next year in Arts Festival called: "Wong Kah Wai's Dream"... I think you will be interested... but come with an open mind... it's not in WKW style. ;)
Happy New Year pal!
Paradoxical... you are indeed struggling...
ReplyDelete"sympathy is easy to feel, but i don't quite think that i have the right to sympathize her."
I'll have to agree... In fact I feel condescending if you do anything out of sympathy for someone else... it's actually a form of mockery, mask in the light of morality. To sympathise with someone, or worse, to be in need of sympathy. Do I sound cold, inhuman? Perhaps to others... but the root itself is infact, on the contrary, based on humanity and humility. I think sympathy for others entails you being in a more fortunate situation and that's really condescending if you feel sympathy for others because you are thinking that you are more fortunate. So yes, no one has the right to sympathise with her... That's what I think... Working with the down syndrome kids recently I realised to sympathise with them is actually an immorale subconscious discrimination... They don't need your sympathy... it makes them "lesser", or feel pathetic... You don't go "awww poor thing"...
I believe in compassion and love... not sympathy... OHMMMMM
Update.. I put the "s" in subconscious... no pun intended :P
ah~!
ReplyDeleteand wow.
you doing a show called 'WKW's dream? Yes, I will be delighted and most honored to catch it.
Good year to you too!
never been more well put...
ReplyDeletehence, sym"pathetic"...=P
ReplyDeleteThanks for the thoughtful post... will update you on the show.
welcome to night life ..
ReplyDeleteI often find myself with overwhelming symphathy which I only managed to overcome it as I get older. In the past, seeing a sick old man collecting plates at hawkercentre would affect my mood the whole day and it took me very long to convince myself that he would be fine, he probably enjoyed working. However, I don't derive the word sympathy the way you do, sympathy is not taking pity, it's an impulse side of compassion, it's a combination of favor,support and loyalty (check dic :P). "the fact or power of sharing the feelings of another, esp. in sorrow or trouble; fellow feeling, compassion, or commiseration". I feel for them, tell me it's none of my business but if I see the hostess probably, I will have the urge to give her a hug...
ReplyDeleteThat's why I have to engage respect and trust in my sympathy as a balance. I feel for them, I try to give them support but I respect and trust that they are able to solve their problem themselves..
If you see the moment of the hostess (Editted, oops, i'm sorry) crying as a picture, without sympathy, you might not be able to catch the beauty of it, yeah maybe, yes, as a picture! That's probably why Raknax think that WKW's style as pridefully numb and over self-indulged...
It depends really... I'd rather not show sympathy still... but I will be compassionate... it's just words at the end of the day. I still help old ladies carry stuffs for no reasons, give up my sit anytime in the day for anyone who needs it... work with down syndrome kids, buy tissue from the auntie at mrt station, still donates on a monthly commitment. But I don't do them out of sympathy because I don't look at them as lesser... they are equals if not someone "more" as they are seniors, they are handicapped people who made it in life and i give my utmost respect to them... not becoz I feel sympathy for them.... I really don't live by the dictionary... I prefer to define words for myself more spiritually... the dictionary is not bible to me. Buddhist believe in compassion... not sympathy... but I am not saying you are wrong, I think it's a matter of words, choice of words, and meaning of words (not definitions).... epistemologically as well as philosophically.
ReplyDeleteIf I see the girl crying on the floor (erm dessy she is not a prostitute) I will squat down and give her a tissue, smile at her, touch her head slightly and tell her don't worry, it's ok.. I'll block the scene for you... but problem is I am not there... so I saw a scenario where Raknax is a character very much atuned to WKW's film... erm not da whole picture ... we are speaking subjectively and metaphorically and not discussing about the girl hence the alienation... not becoz we are uncompassionate? But honestly... I do not sympathise with her... because I can't ... we can't... according to your definition... we can't possibly feel how she feel... no way and no right to... but will we help her? For me, yes... but not out of sympathy....
In anycase, I don't think you are wrong.. and I think you feel sympathy "out of compassion and love" so we are quite on the same page... just usage of words I tend to be a little stricter with what a word entails than a dictionary would suggest because life is more complex than (or simpler) than dat. ;)
Happy new year to all! PEACE!
Thanks for explaining darren, I will try to understand, the differences... compassion, love and sympathy :)
ReplyDelete2007 is a yr of hope to me, happy new year!
the word 'sympathy' was originated with better intentions, however with its usage erosion and abuse by opportunists turned philanthropists and celebrities whom try to achieve a human side by gracing third world countries with their presences. it really drew a not so invisible line of 'us and them', thus labelling the less unfortunates as the weaker group.
ReplyDeletei agree with Dessy that sympathy was supposed to be pure and altruistic, an important emotion to put ourselves in the shoes of the others. and it is refreshing to think that with a pinch of curious sympathy of the hostess' tears, then i was able, for that moment in eternity grasp that Wong Kar Wai's vision of beauty in solidarity and mystery.
Darren on the other hand (if i could claim so), is a rebel at heart. Thus having different expectations if not more stringent ones. I don't know whether is it a guy thing or not, like him, I too feel that the modern usage of 'sympathy' was... not as it was meant originally. Instead of trying to put ourselves in other's shoes, it created a 'us or them' distance.
But Dessy, value your sympathies. I find them pure and well intended. Many people around will find solace in them.
Darren, you can throw me rocks if you want to, but allow me to say this: i think that we are both sorta jaded and numbed and maybe a little stubborn ... sorta like the unwilling pawns in WKW. Romanticism in absurdity. That's a good one, I got to remember that.
it's all a matter of perceptions. No one is right and no one is wrong. And we got to know each other better, i think that's what is important.
ok Darren, u can throw me rocks now for me being too assuming.
Haha good one... Love your analysis... perhaps you are right in saying it cud be a guy thing or that we are too jaded. I respect Dessy's sympathy and POV, but i felt she mistook us as unsympathetic or cold so felt the need to explain to her my stand. No I won't throw rocks at you, there's no right or wrong as I had also said earlier, just words that meant different things to us because of perceptions and experiences in life...
ReplyDeleteLook where your post led us to... love these small intellectual tidbits... it's refreshing. :)
It's indeed very refreshing darren. :)
ReplyDeleteThanks raknax, you totally explain what I want to express. winks*
The truth of the matter is, the act of selling intimacies, however diluted with alcohol, is inherently tragic. Although she weeps for herself, you found her sorrow captivating because it is the only proper humane response for the whole scenario. Against the backdrop of artifice, you were given a moment of sheer honesty. That was what made the whole thing beautiful.
ReplyDeleteBeautifully explained :)
ReplyDeletegiven time, she might learn not to cry anymore, she will grow the necessary mechanism of defense with enough denial and self justifications, she might no longer hear her soul beckoning, she will be older and she will be hardened. She will learn to tell herself what is necessary to tell herself so that she could adapt, to immune.
ReplyDeletemaybe that's why her tears are so precious now. the vulnerability of self awareness. the human capability to still get hurt, to still feel.
I now know why....
i'm a jerk becos i like to see people vulnerable. and tears fascinate me because i couldn't cry any more. when people are vulnerable, it show that they are still liable to get hurt, it's an expression of a crack or a weakness. and i like human weakness and i like human flaws, becos human weakness tell us that the host is -
genuine and very very real.
I'm not a jerk, i'm not that grand yet. i'm just someone who is eager to recover the age of innocence through the eyes of others.
"i'm a jerk becos i like to see people vulnerable. and tears fascinate me because i couldn't cry any more. when people are vulnerable, it show that they are still liable to get hurt, it's an expression of a crack or a weakness. and i like human weakness and i like human flaws, becos human weakness tell us that the host is -
ReplyDeletegenuine and very very real."
Welcome to the club... :) I was or maybe am a jerk because I am attracted to vulnerability. It's hard to explain. Soon you will find that there's no point to cry at all... no point for anyone to feel sad for oneself and you will start to see life in it's true essence... in it's true beauty... ;)